| 2004-2005 | |
| Sleuth | Anthony Shaffer |
| The Weekend | Michael Palin |
| Beyond Reasonable Doubt | Jeffrey Archer |
| The Boyfriend | Sandy Wilson |
| Cat On A Hot Tin Roof | Tennessee Williams |
| Inside Trading | Malcolm Bradbury |
| The Herbal Bed | Peter Whelan |
| The Cemetary Club | Ivan Menchall |
| Anne Of Green Gables | Alice Chadwicke |
| 2003-2004 | |
| Blue Remembered Hills & other plays | Dennis Potter |
| The Memory of Water | Shelagh Stephenson |
| Outside Edge | Richard Harris |
| The Fantastiks | Tom Jones & Harvey Schmidt |
| Ghosts | Henrik Ibsen |
| Habeas Corpus | Alan Bennett |
| Educating Rita | Willy Russell |
| Murder by the Book | Duncan Greenwood & Robert King |
| Beauty & the Beast | Laurence Boswell |
| 2002-2003 | |
| Falstaff | Adapted by Michael Pilch (William Shakespeare) |
| Chapter II | Neil Simon |
| A Day in the Death of Joe Egg | Peter Nicholls |
| The Importance of Not Being Gilbert | Colin Pearson |
| Private Lives | Noel Coward |
| All My Sons | Arthur Miller |
| What the Butler Saw | Joe Orton |
| Quartet | Ronald Harwood |
| David Copperfield | Matthew Francis (Charles Dickens) |
| 2001-2002 | |
| California Suite | Neil Simon |
| Amy's View | David Hare |
| Dial 'M' for Murder | Frederick Knott |
| Dick Whittington | Norman Robbins |
| Of Mice and Men | John Steinbeck |
| Pardon me Prime Minister | Edward Taylor & John Graham |
| Talking Heads | Alan Bennett |
| Miss Roach's War | Richard Kane |
| Jack the Ripper | Ron Pember & Denis de Marne |
| 2000-2001 | |
| Move Over Mrs Markham | Ray Cooney & John Chapman |
| A Letter of Resignation | Hugh Whitemore |
| The Wind in the Willows | Alan Bennett (Kenneth Grahame) |
| Gaslight | Patrick Hamilton |
| One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest | Dale Wasserman (Kesey) |
| Kafka's Dick | Alan Bennett |
| I Never Sang for my Father | Robert Anderson |
| Twelfth Night | William Shakespeare |
| 1999-2000 | |
| Dead-Lock | Hugh Janes |
| A Man for all Seasons | Robert Bolt |
| Season's Greetings | Alan Ayckbourn |
| Jack and the Beanstalk | Peter Denyer |
| Same Time Next Year | Bernard Slade |
| Travels with my Aunt | Giles Havergal (Grahame Greene) |
| Taking Sides | Ronald Harwood |
| My Mother Said I Never Should | Charlotte Keatley |
| Arsenic and Old Lace | Joseph Kesselring |
| 1998-1999 | |
| It Runs in the Family | Ray Cooney |
| Steel Magnolias | Robert Harling |
| The Madness of George III | Alan Bennett |
| Christmas Music Hall | |
| The Business of Murder | Richard Harris |
| The Crucible | Arthur Miller |
| Straight and Narrow | Jimmie Chinn |
| A Doll's House | Henrik Ibsen (Michael Meyer) |
| Salad Days | Dorothy Reynolds & Julian Slade |
| 1997-1998 | |
| Shadowlands | William Nicholson |
| Breaking the Silence | Stephen Poliakoff |
| Racing Demon | David Hare |
| The Lone Stranger | Peter Whittle & Jerry Phillips |
| Dancing at Lughnasa | Brian Friel |
| Death and the Maiden | Ariel Dorfman |
| When we are Married | J.B.Priestley |
| A Streetcar Named Desire | Tennessee Williams |
| King Lear | William Shakespeare |
| 1996-1997 | |
| A View from the Bridge | Arthur Miller |
| Absurd Person Singular | Alan Ayckbourn |
| Look Back in Anger | John Osborne |
| Cabaret | Joe Masteroff & John Kander (Van Druten) |
| Lost in Yonkers | Neil Simon |
| The Wind of Heaven | Emlyn Williams |
| The Browning Version/The Real Inspector Hound | Terence Rattigan/Tom Stoppard |
| Hamp | John Wilson |
| Charley's Aunt | Brandon Thomas |
| 1995-1996 | |
| The Deep Blue Sea | Terence Rattigan |
| Nasty Neighbours | Debbie Issit |
| Much Ado About Nothing | William Shakespeare |
| Aladdin | Barbara Beckett |
| A Life | Hugh Leonard |
| An Evening with Gary Lineker | Arthur Smith & Chris England |
| Blood Relations | Sharron Pollock |
| Out of Order | Ray Cooney |
| The Fifteen Streets | Rob Bettinson (Catherine Cookson) |
| 1994-1995 | |
| Abelard and Heloise | Ronald Miller |
| Middle-Age Spread | Roger Hall |
| Cider with Rosie | Michael Pilch (Laurie Lee) |
| The Magic of Pinocchio | Raymond Jones-Davies (Collodi) |
| Shirley Valentine | Willy Russell |
| Spark in Judea | R.F. Delderfield |
| Shock! | Brian Clemens |
| The Sunshine Boys | Neil Simon |
| Les Liaisons Dangereuses | Christopher Hampton (Laclos) |
| 1993-1994 | |
| Stepping Out | Richard Harris |
| Shakespeare Country | Peter Whelan |
| Therese Raquin | Leslie Sands (Emile Zola) |
| Jack and the Beanstalk | Peter Whittle |
| The Road to Mecca | Athol Fugard |
| Uncle Vanya | Anton Chekhov (Michael Frayn) |
| Run for Your Wife | Ray Cooney |
| Twelve Angry Men | Reginald Rose |
| Affairs in a Tent | Alan Ayckbourn |
| 1992-1993 | |
| Da | Hugh Leonard |
| Brighton Beach Memoirs | Neil Simon |
| Adam Bede | Geoffrey Beevers (George Eliot) |
| Worzel Gummidge | Keith Waterhouse & Willis Hall |
| Not Now Darling | Ray Cooney & John Chapman |
| The Accrington Pals | Peter Whelan |
| A Chorus of Disapproval | Alan Ayckbourn |
| Wait until Dark | Frederick Knott |
| Present Laughter | Noel Coward |
| 1991-1992 | |
| Relatively Speaking | Alan Ayckbourn |
| La Ronde | Arthur Schnitzler (Michael Pilch) |
| Daisy Pulls it Off | Denise Deegan |
| Goldilocks and the Three Bears | Peter Whittle |
| Breaking the Code | Hugh Whitemore |
| Lettice & Lovage | Peter Shaffer |
| Dangerous Obsession | N.J. Crisp |
| Lend me a Tenor | Ken Ludwig |
| The Merchant of Venice | William Shakespeare |
| 1990-1991 | |
| Rattle of a Simple Man | Charles Dyer |
| Amadeus | Peter Shaffer |
| The Memorandum | Vaclav Havel (Vera Blackwell) |
| See How they Run | Philip King |
| Liz | Peter Motley (Aristophanes) |
| Cause Celebre | Terence Rattigan |
| The Rivals | Richard Brinsley Sheridan |
| Deathtrap | Ira Levin |
| Our Country's Good | Timberlake Wertenbaker |
| Say Something Happened/Bazaar & Rummage | Alan Bennett/Sue Townsend |
| 1989-1990 | |
| A Month of Sundays | Bob Larbey |
| How the Other Half Loves | Alan Ayckbourn |
| Dirty Linen/Newfoundland | Tom Stoppard |
| Night Errant/Nothing On | George Feydeau (Michael Pilch) |
| The Entertainer | John Osborne |
| Cyrano de Bergerac | Edmond Rostand (Anthony Burgess) |
| The Sleeping Prince | Terence Rattigan |
| The Golden Pathway Annual | John Harding & John Burrows |
| Tons of Money | Will Evans & Valentine |
| Steaming | Nell Dunn |
| Three Sisters | Anton Chekhov (Michael Frayn) |
| The Comedy of Errors | William Shakespeare |
| 1988-1989 | |
| Noises Off | Michael Frayn |
| The Barretts of Wimpole Street | Rudolf Besier |
| Dark of the Moon | Howard Richardson & William Berney |
| Toad of Toad Hall | A.A. Milne (Kenneth Grahame) |
| Death of a Salesman | Arthur Miller |
| Benefactors | Michael Frayn |
| Twelfth Night | William Shakespeare |
| The Secret Diary of Adrian Mole | Sue Townsend |
| The Bacchae | Euripides (William Arrowsmith) |
| 1987-1988 | |
| Round and Round the Garden | Alan Ayckbourn |
| Betrayal | Harold Pinter |
| The Lion in Winter | James Goldman |
| Babes in the Wood | Roger Starbuck |
| Donkey's Years | Michael Frayn |
| Time and the Conways | J.B. Priestley |
| Pack of Lies | Hugh Whitemore |
| Two Stars for Comfort | John Mortimer |
| Billy Liar | Keith Waterhouse & Willis Hall |
| The Importance of Being Ernest | Oscar Wilde |
| 1986-1987 | |
| Taking Steps | Alan Ayckbourn |
| Smile, Please | Michael Pilch |
| The Anniversary | Bill MacIllwraith |
| Cinderella | Barbara Beckett |
| The Sound of Murder | William Fairchild |
| The Real Thing | Tom Stoppard |
| On Golden Pond | Ernest Thompson |
| Confusions | Alan Ayckbourn |
| Summer of the Seventeenth Doll | Ray Lawler |
| Macbeth | William Shakespeare |
| 1985-1986 | |
| The Odd Couple | Neil Simon |
| Can You Hear Me at the Back? | Brian Clark |
| 84 Charing Cross Road | James Roose-Evans (Helene Hanff) |
| Mother Goose | Peter Whittle |
| September Tide | Daphne du Maurier |
| Lent | Michael Wilcox |
| Quartermaine's Terms | Simon Gray |
| Blithe Spirit | Noel Coward |
| Panic Stations | Derek Benfield |
| The Taming of the Shrew | William Shakespeare |
| 1984-1985 | |
| In Praise of Love | Terence Rattigan |
| A Midsummer Night's Dream | William Shakespeare |
| Murder in Mind | Terence Feely |
| The Adventures of a Bear called Paddington | Alfred Bradley & Michael Bond |
| Saturday, Sunday, Monday | Eduardo de Filippo |
| Made Over | Michael Pilch |
| A Month in the Country | Ivan Turgenev (Emlyn Williams) |
| Hay Fever | Noel Coward |
| Local Affairs | Richard Harris |
| Educating Rita | Willy Russell |
| 1983-1984 | |
| The Philanthropist | Christopher Hampton |
| Outside Edge | Richard Harris |
| Trevor/Black Comedy | John Bowen/Peter Shaffer |
| All My Sons | Arthur Miller |
| Dick Whittington | Peter Whittle |
| I Remember Mama | John Van Druten |
| Sisterly Feelings | Alan Ayckbourn |
| The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie | Jay Presson Allen |
| The Alchemist | Ben Jonson |
| Happy Birthday | Marc Camoletti |
| Celebration | Keith Waterhouse & Willis Hall |
| 1982-1983 | |
| Living Together | Alan Ayckbourn |
| The Civil Servant | Michael Pilch (Nikolai Gogol) |
| Stevie | Hugh Whitemore |
| Female Transport | Steve Gooch |
| The Gingerbread Man | David Wood |
| The Family Dance | Felicity Browne |
| The Dresser | Ronald Harwood |
| Ghosts | Henrik Ibsen (Michael Meyer) |
| An Inspector Calls | J.B. Priestley |
| Time and Time Again | Alan Ayckbourn |
| Come Blow your Horn | Neil Simon |
| Sleuth | Anthony Shaffer |
| 1981-1982 | |
| Godspell | John-Michael Tebelak & Stephen Schwartz |
| The Tempest | William Shakespeare |
| Barefoot in the Park | Neil Simon |
| Aladdin | Del Harman |
| A Voyage Round my Father | John Mortimer |
| Whose Life is it Anyway? | Brian Clark |
| The Killing of Sister George | Frank Marcus |
| Alphabetical Order | Michael Frayn |
| Pygmalion | George Bernard Shaw |
| Rose | Andrew Davies |
| 1980-1981 | |
| Night Must Fall | Emlyn Williams |
| The Cherry Orchard | Anton Chekhov (Michael Frayn) |
| The Crucible | Arthur Miller |
| The Land of XYZ | Esther Weatherill |
| Bedroom Farce | Alan Ayckbourn |
| Habeas Corpus | Alan Bennett |
| The Cocktail Party | T.S. Eliot |
| The Glass Menagerie | Tennessee Williams |
| Hobson's Choice | Harold Brighouse |
| The Monte Carlo Telegram | Grant Eustace |
| 1979-1980 | |
| One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest | Dale Wasserman (Kesey) |
| Roots | Arnold Wesker |
| The Pickwick Club | Michael Pilch (Charles Dickens) |
| Sabrina Fair | Samuel Taylor |
| The Owl and the Pussycat | Sheila Ruskin & David Wood |
| The Chalk Garden | Enig Bagnold |
| The Way of the World | William Congreve |
| The Seven Year Itch | George Axelrod |
| Say Goodnight to Grandma | Colin Welland |
| She Stoops to Conquer | Oliver Goldsmith |
| The Birthday Party | Harold Pinter |
| Man of la Mancha | Dale Wasserman |
| 1978-1979 | |
| The Winslow Boy | Terence Rattigan |
| Under Milk Wood | Dylan Thomas |
| Table Manners | Alan Ayckbourn |
| Robinson Crusoe | Del Harman |
| Arsenic and Old Lace | Joseph Kesselring |
| Equus | Peter Shaffer |
| Oh What a Lovely War | Charles Chilton & others |
| Hamlet | William Shakespeare |
| There's a Girl in my Soup | Terence Frisby |
| What the Butler Saw | Joe Orton |
| 1977-1978 | |
| All in Good Time | Bill Naughton |
| Forget-me-not Lane | Peter Nichols |
| Jack and the Beanstalk | Del Harman |
| A Doll's House | Henrik Ibsen (Michael Meyer) |
| Absurd Person Singular | Alan Ayckbourn |
| Cider with Rosie | Michael Pilch (Laurie Lee) |
| The Dame of Sark | William Douglas Home |
| Zoo, Zoo, Widdershins Zoo | K.B. Laffan |
| Crown Matrimonial | Royce Ryton |
| A Resounding Tinkle/Us and Them | N.F. Simpson/David Campton |